Chapter 3: Practical tips for trustworthy OER reuse, adaptation and co-creation
Marta Bustillo; Paola Corti; Claudia Hackl-Mayerhofer; and Sylvia Moes
Reviewers: Lilianna Nalewajska, Celine Peignen, David Stoellger
Keywords: OER quality, quality assurance, trust, copyright and licensing, Creative Commons, OER reuse and adaptation, co-creation, student–staff–library collaboration, Open Educational Practices
UNESCO OER Recommendation areas:
(i) building capacity of stakeholders to create, access, re-use, adapt and redistribute OER;
(iii) encouraging inclusive and equitable quality OER;
(iv) nurturing the creation of sustainability models for OER;
Target audience: Educators, librarians, instructional designers, educational developers, students involved in OER creation and co-creation, copyright and licensing support staff, and Open Education practitioners.
Before you dive into the chapter
This chapter explores Open Educational Practices that support the responsible evaluation, reuse, adaptation, creation, and sharing of OER. As you move through the chapter, you will encounter approaches and resources for building trust in the quality of existing OER, navigating copyright and open licensing, and developing successful collaborative approaches to OER creation involving students, staff, and libraries. Together, these perspectives provide practical starting points for developing Open Educational Practices that can be applied and adapted in different educational and institutional contexts.
The Reused Resources featured in this chapter are collected in an appendix, where you can explore practical resources related to the chapter topics and consider how they might be reused or adapted in your own context.
The learning outcomes below provide an overview of take away from the chapter. At the end of the chapter, Key Takeaways summarise the central messages, while Questions to Consider invite you to reflect on what you have explored and connect it to your own professional, institutional, or educational context.
Learning outcomes
After reading this chapter, you will be able to:
- Evaluate the quality and suitability of existing OER using relevant criteria, frameworks, and quality assurance approaches.
- Identify key copyright and licensing considerations when reusing, adapting, remixing, and sharing OER.
- Apply appropriate open licensing and attribution practices when creating, adapting, and sharing OER.
- Recognise the value of student–staff–library collaboration in the creation and development of OER.
- Identify approaches and conditions that can support successful collaborative and co-creative OER practices.
For usability and accessibility reasons, all links in this textbook open in the same browser tab. Tip: If you prefer to open a link in a new tab, right-click the link and select “Open link in new tab” (or use the equivalent option on your device).
Chapter 3 Introduction
Open Educational Resources (OER) have the potential to transform teaching and learning by enabling educators and institutions to freely access, adapt, and share educational materials. However, making effective use of OER requires more than simply publishing resources under an open licence. Sustainable Open Education initiatives depend on a range of Open Educational Practices (OEP) that support the responsible evaluation, creation, adaptation, reuse, and sharing of open materials.
Educators, librarians, and institutions often encounter practical challenges when working with OER. These challenges include concerns about the quality and trustworthiness of existing resources, uncertainties regarding copyright and licensing, and questions about how to organise successful collaborative development processes. Addressing these challenges requires not only appropriate tools and frameworks, but also knowledge, confidence, collaboration, and institutional support.
In this chapter, we explore three interconnected dimensions of Open Educational Practice:
- Building trust in the quality of existing OER
- Navigating the legal complexities of reusing, remixing, and sharing OER
- Making OER co-creation and collaboration work
These three dimensions reflect different but closely connected aspects of working with OER in practice. Quality and trust influence whether educators feel confident selecting and reusing existing resources. Legal understanding enables OER to be reused, adapted, remixed, attributed, and shared responsibly. Collaborative approaches can bring together different forms of expertise and perspectives, creating opportunities for students, educators, librarians, and other stakeholders to actively participate in developing educational resources.
The interconnected nature of these challenges can also be illustrated through the OER Adoption Pyramid developed by Cox and Trotter (2017). The framework identifies six factors that influence OER adoption: access, permission, awareness, capacity, availability, and volition. The lower levels of the pyramid represent conditions over which individual educators generally have less control, while the upper levels are increasingly influenced by individual agency.
Several of these factors are directly connected to the practices explored in this chapter. Permission relates to copyright and open licensing; capacity includes the knowledge and skills needed to find, use, adapt, and create OER; and availability concerns not only whether OER exist, but also whether relevant and sufficiently high-quality resources are available for a particular context. The framework therefore illustrates why successful OER reuse and adaptation depend on a combination of legal, practical, institutional, and individual conditions (Cox & Trotter, 2017).

Rather than approaching these areas in isolation, the chapter considers how they interact. Evaluating an existing OER may lead to questions about whether and how it can be adapted. Adaptation requires an understanding of licensing and attribution, while creating or adapting resources collaboratively introduces questions about roles, responsibilities, contributions, and effective partnership. Open Educational Practices provide a broader framework through which these different considerations can be connected.
By grounding the discussion in practical experiences, examples, and existing resources, this chapter aims to provide readers with both conceptual understanding and actionable strategies. The resources and approaches presented throughout the chapter can also serve as starting points for reuse and adaptation in different professional, educational, and institutional contexts.
3.1 Trust in the quality of existing OER
This section explores how educators, librarians, repositories, and Open Education communities can support informed decisions about the selection and reuse of OER.
Quality is a frequently discussed challenge in the adoption and reuse of Open Educational Resources (OER). Educators may be uncertain about the academic reliability, pedagogical suitability, accessibility, or technical quality of openly available materials. Research on OER has identified quality assurance as both a challenge and an opportunity for the sustainable development and use of OER (Camilleri et al., 2014). European research involving academic libraries similarly shows that quality and trust remain practical concerns in Open Education (Santos-Hermosa et al., 2022).
Quality in OER cannot simply be understood as a distinction between “good” and “bad” resources. There is no single agreed definition or approach to OER quality, and the suitability of a resource also depends on its educational context and intended purpose (Camilleri et al., 2014). A resource that works well for one course, group of learners, language, or educational system may require adaptation before it is useful in another.
Research also illustrates how quality and trust can influence OER adoption. In the study by Baas et al. (2019), 83.2% of participating teachers indicated that they preferred OER created by an author or institution with a good reputation, while 54.6% preferred resources recommended by someone they knew or trusted. Reputation and personal recommendation can therefore function as useful trust signals when educators encounter unfamiliar OER. However, they should not be treated as evidence of accuracy, accessibility, pedagogical suitability, or contextual relevance by themselves. Reliance on established authors, institutions, or networks may also reproduce prestige bias and make community- or student-created, or less institutionally visible resources appear less trustworthy, even when they may be valuable and appropriate for a particular context. For this reason, reputation should be considered alongside other evaluation criteria, including content accuracy, licensing clarity, accessibility, adaptability, learner needs, and fitness for purpose.
Using the OER Adoption Pyramid as their conceptual framework, Baas et al. (2019) also draw attention to availability, which encompasses not only whether OER can be found, but also their perceived relevance and quality. Their findings suggest that the relationship between the factors in the pyramid may vary by context and that availability may need to be considered earlier in the adoption process.
The same study also highlights the close relationship between trust, quality, and findability. Only 11.2% of participating teachers reported knowing where to find OER, while interview participants described finding suitable, high-quality resources as requiring considerable time and effort (Baas et al., 2019). This suggests that supporting OER adoption involves not only helping educators evaluate resources once they have found them, but also making trustworthy and relevant OER easier to discover.
Quality should therefore be considered not only as a characteristic of a resource, but also in relation to its fitness for purpose.
What do we mean by quality in OER?
OER quality can involve multiple dimensions rather than a single characteristic. Research and existing evaluation approaches address aspects such as content quality and accuracy, pedagogy, usability, technical characteristics, accessibility, licensing, and opportunities for reuse and adaptation (Camilleri et al., 2014; Yuan & Recker, 2015).
Depending on the purpose and context of use, relevant dimensions may include:
- Content accuracy and reliability: Is the information accurate, current, appropriately referenced, and suitable for the subject area?
- Pedagogical quality: Does the resource support the intended learning objectives and activities?
- Accessibility and inclusion: Can learners with different needs access and engage with the resource?
- Usability and technical quality: Is the resource easy to access, navigate, and use?
- Openness and adaptability: Is the licence clearly stated, and can the resource realistically be reused or adapted?
- Findability and transparency: Are authorship, licence, date or version, sources, and relevant metadata available?
- Contextual relevance: Is the resource appropriate for the learners, discipline, language, cultural context, and educational environment?
- Cultural and linguistic responsiveness: Does the resource avoid cultural or linguistic bias, and does it support meaningful use across different learner groups, languages, and contexts?
- Representation and epistemic diversity: Whose knowledge, perspectives, examples, and voices are included or excluded, and does the resource allow room for alternative or underrepresented perspectives?
- Versioning and correction mechanisms: Is there information about version history, updates, corrections, or ways for users to report issues and contribute improvements?
- Transparency around AI-generated or AI-assisted content: If AI tools were used to generate, translate, summarise, adapt, or illustrate the resource, is this disclosed clearly enough for users to evaluate the material and verify it where needed?
These dimensions do not carry the same weight in every situation. An academically accurate and well-designed OER may still not be suitable for a particular course, whereas an OER that requires (and allows) adaptation may provide an excellent starting point precisely because its openness invites reuse, modification, and recontextualisation.
Rather than asking only “Is this a high-quality OER?”, it can therefore be more useful to ask:
“Is this OER trustworthy, appropriate, accessible, adaptable, and fit for my particular purpose? If something needs to be changed for a better fit, can I adapt it?”
Approaches to evaluating OER quality
A range of rubrics, frameworks, and checklists has been developed to support the systematic evaluation of OER. A review by Yuan and Recker (2015) identified considerable diversity among OER quality rubrics, including differences in criteria, rating systems, empirical validation, and user support. Evaluation frameworks should therefore support informed professional judgement rather than simply provide a universal “pass” or “fail” judgement.
ENOEL provides a practical example of this approach through its Embrace the Open: OE Librarianship 101 workshop. One of its explicit learning outcomes is to enable librarians to select criteria for identifying high-quality OER collections for their own Open Education projects. The workshop connected this process to reusability, adaptability, shareability, licensing, and the role of librarians in Open Educational Practices (European Network of Open Education Librarians, 2024).
Questions to ask when evaluating an OER
- Content: Is the information accurate, current, appropriately referenced, and relevant?
- Pedagogy: Does the resource support the intended learning objectives and activities?
- Context: Is it appropriate for the learners, discipline, educational level, language, and cultural context?
- Accessibility and inclusion: Can learners with different needs access and engage with the resource?
- Usability: Is the resource technically functional, clearly structured, and easy to navigate?
- Openness: Is the licence clear, and does it permit the intended reuse or adaptation?
- Adaptability: Can the resource realistically be modified, translated, updated, or localised?
- Transparency: Are authorship, sources, licence, date or version, and other relevant information clearly provided?
These questions can be adapted to institutional, disciplinary, or pedagogical contexts and can provide a starting point for local OER evaluation guidance.
A useful European example of this contextual approach is the SURF Roadmap quality model for open learning materials (English version). Rather than prescribing a single universal definition of quality, the resource supports higher education institutions and subject communities in developing, implementing, and maintaining their own quality model. Such a model can provide educators with shared criteria for assessing whether open learning materials are suitable for use, while allowing those criteria to reflect disciplinary, institutional, and educational contexts. (SURF, n.d.)
How do repositories, peer review, and metadata support trust?
Quality assessment does not rest with individual educators alone. Repositories, communities, and institutions can provide additional mechanisms that help users make informed decisions.
Research on OER repositories has identified peer review, user evaluation, authorship information, standardised metadata, licence information, and access to original files among relevant indicators for supporting quality, openness, reuse, and collaboration (Atenas & Havemann, 2013, 2014). A broader review of quality approaches in repositories similarly found peer review and recommendation systems among the most frequently discussed quality mechanisms and highlighted the potential of collaborative, user-generated quality approaches (Clements et al., 2015).
Baas et al. (2019) indicate that teachers may benefit from support in finding relevant OER, including subject-specific overviews, curated collections, and communities or databases that make visible who teaches in a particular area and where relevant expertise can be found.
Metadata is particularly important for informed reuse. Information about authorship, educational level, subject, language, licence, format, date or version does not make an OER high-quality in itself, but it helps users assess its suitability and provenance (Atenas & Havemann, 2014).
Trust therefore emerges not only from the content of an OER, but also from the information, review processes, communities, and infrastructures surrounding it.
The role of libraries and support professionals
Libraries and educational support services can play an active role in assessing OER quality, while recognising that different dimensions of quality may require different forms of expertise. Librarians and support professionals are particularly well placed to make informed judgements about quality markers such as metadata, licensing, attribution, accessibility, discoverability, and transparency, because their profession often combines information literacy, copyright and licensing knowledge, metadata and discovery practices, and support for accessible and responsible reuse. Other dimensions, including disciplinary accuracy, currency, pedagogical fit, and learner suitability, may require closer collaboration with educators, subject specialists, students, or relevant communities. Quality assessment can therefore be understood as a collaborative process in which librarians contribute their specific expertise alongside other stakeholders’.
This role also responds to practical needs identified by educators. In the study by Baas et al. (2019), teachers expressed a particular need for subject-specific overviews of available OER, curated resources, communities, and technical and pedagogical support. The authors consequently identify searching, selecting, and curating OER as areas where librarians can take an active role, alongside broader institutional efforts to increase OER awareness and adoption.
European studies show that academic libraries are increasingly involved in supporting Open Education. The SPARC Europe surveys, developed in consultation and collaboration with ENOEL, document library engagement with OER and identify both opportunities and challenges related to quality, trust, skills, reuse, and institutional support (Proudman et al., 2020; Santos-Hermosa et al., 2022). Research examining the implementation of the UNESCO Recommendation on OER further demonstrates library activity across its five areas of action, including the area concerned with inclusive and equitable quality OER (Santos-Hermosa, 2024).
Libraries and support professionals can contribute by:
- helping educators discover and evaluate OER;
- developing or adapting evaluation frameworks;
- supporting metadata and discoverability;
- contributing to repository curation and review processes;
- providing guidance on licensing and attribution;
- supporting professional development; and
- connecting educators with relevant disciplinary and Open Education communities.
ENOEL’s OE Librarianship 101 workshop translated this role into practice by combining the identification of high-quality OER collections with reflection on how librarians can contribute to Open Educational Practices (European Network of Open Education Librarians, 2024).
Openness as a mechanism for quality improvement
Openness also creates opportunities to understand quality as an iterative process rather than only a characteristic of a finished product. The freedoms associated with OER can blur traditional boundaries between creation, evaluation, use, and improvement (Camilleri et al., 2014). This does not remove the need for quality assurance systems; rather, it shows why different forms of quality support are needed, including peer review, repository practices, user feedback, versioning, accessibility checks, and community-based evaluation. Under these conditions, openness can contribute to trust by making the history, use, improvement, and possible limitations of a resource more visible.
Where licensing permissions and editable formats allow, OER can be corrected, updated, translated, localised, reorganised, or adapted to improve accessibility and pedagogical relevance. Collaborative and user-generated quality approaches can be particularly valuable within OER ecosystems (Clements et al., 2015).
Openness alone does not guarantee quality improvement. It also requires expertise, time, suitable formats, infrastructure, and communities that support reuse and adaptation. Nevertheless, it enables an important shift in perspective. Instead of asking only:
“Is this resource good enough to use?”
We can also ask:
“Is this a resource that we can build on?”
Quality assurance and openness are therefore not opposing concepts. Critical evaluation, transparent information, reuse, adaptation, peer and community review, and collaboration can all contribute to building trust and improving OER over time.
From quality assessment to reuse
Evaluating an OER is an important first step in deciding whether it can support a particular teaching and learning context. Finding and evaluating an OER does not automatically lead to adaptation. In the study by Baas et al. (2019), teachers who used OER tended to use them “as-is” or as inspiration for developing their own materials, while adaptation was less common and was associated with concerns about the time and skills required. Supporting OER reuse, therefore, also means helping educators develop the confidence, skills, and practical conditions needed to move from finding resources towards adapting them for their own teaching contexts. Once a suitable resource has been identified, another set of questions emerges:
- What teaching or learning need should this resource support?
- Which parts of the resource are already suitable, and which parts would need to be changed?
- Does the licence allow the kind of reuse or adaptation I have in mind?
- Is the resource available in a format that can realistically be edited, translated, updated, or remixed?
- What information do I need to record about the title, author, source, licence, and any changes made?
- Are there accessibility, language, cultural, or representation issues that should be addressed before reuse?
- If I adapt the resource, where and how can I share the new version so that others can find and reuse it?
For example, an educator may find an openly licensed slide deck that is accurate and relevant but designed for a different national context. If the licence allows adaptation and the slides are available in an editable format, the educator could translate key terms, replace examples, add local policy references, check accessibility, record attribution, and share the adapted version with a clear licence statement.
However, what legal frameworks and open licensing practices exist that enable (and sometimes limit) the reuse, adaptation, remixing, and sharing of OER?
3.2 Legal complexities of reusing, remixing, and sharing OER
A central promise of Open Educational Resources (OER) lies in the possibility to reuse, adapt, and redistribute educational materials. However, educators may experience uncertainty when dealing with copyright, licensing conditions, attribution requirements, and compatibility between different licences.
Sharing educational resources does not necessarily mean sharing them openly. Baas et al. (2019), for example, found that while 50.3% of the teachers in their study reported sharing educational materials, only 7.7% reported sharing resources with an open licence. Much of the sharing described in the study took place informally within teams or institutions. This distinction highlights why copyright and licensing literacy are important: educators may already have a strong culture of sharing without necessarily using the legal mechanisms that enable resources to be openly reused and adapted.
The UNESCO Recommendation on OER defines OER as learning, teaching, and research materials that are either in the public domain or under copyright and released under an open licence that permits no-cost access, reuse, repurposing, adaptation, and redistribution (UNESCO, 2019). OER may still be protected by copyright, but they are released under an open licence that grants the public specific permissions. In terms of the OER Adoption Pyramid introduced above, these questions relate particularly to permission: educators need to understand both what an existing OER licence permits them to do and whether they have the necessary rights to openly license and share materials they create (Cox & Trotter, 2017).
Creative Commons (CC) licences are among the most widely used mechanisms for granting such permissions. They provide standardised ways for creators to communicate how others may use their work. Understanding their conditions is particularly important when educational materials are reused, adapted, translated, combined, or redistributed (Creative Commons, 2026a).
Please note that this section provides a practical orientation to some of these legal considerations. It is not intended as legal advice. Copyright legislation and institutional requirements differ between jurisdictions, and readers should consult appropriate local legal expertise.
Copyright and Creative Commons licences
Open licensing requires copyright to be in place. An open licence does not mean giving up copyright; the copyright holder retains their rights while allowing others to use the work under the terms of the licence. In many cases, the creator or another rights holder retains copyright but uses an open licence to grant the public permission in advance. UNESCO defines an open licence as one that respects the copyright owner’s intellectual property rights while granting permission to access, reuse, repurpose, adapt, and redistribute educational materials (UNESCO, 2019).
Detailed descriptions of the Creative Commons licences can be found on their Creative Commons website. Find a short summary below:
Creative Commons provides six main copyright licences based on four licence elements (Creative Commons, 2026a):
- BY – Attribution: Since version 2.5, credit must be given to the creator(s) of the licensed material and any others designated to receive attribution.
- SA – ShareAlike: Adaptations that are shared must be licensed under the same or a compatible licence.
- NC – NonCommercial: The material may not be used for commercial purposes under the terms of the licence.
- ND – NoDerivatives: Adaptations may not be shared under the terms of the licence.
These elements can be combined to result in different licences:
- CC BY: reuse, adaptation, and redistribution, including for commercial purposes, with attribution;
- CC BY-SA: reuse and adaptation with attribution, with adaptations shared under the same or a compatible licence;
- CC BY-NC: reuse and adaptation for non-commercial purposes, with attribution. However, the distinction between commercial and non-commercial use is not always clear-cut and may depend on the specific context and applicable legal framework. Where there is uncertainty, the licence terms and relevant legal context should therefore be considered carefully.
- CC BY-NC-SA: non-commercial reuse and adaptation, with attribution and ShareAlike;
- CC BY-ND: redistribution with attribution, but adapted versions may not be shared;
- CC BY-NC-ND: non-commercial redistribution with attribution, but adapted versions may not be shared.
CC0 and Public Domain materials are also important in the context of open reuse:
- CC0 – Public Domain Dedication: This is a legal tool provided by Creative Commons. Creators can use CC0 to waive their copyright and related rights to the fullest extent permitted by law, allowing others to copy, modify, distribute, and use the material without seeking permission or providing attribution. Attribution may nevertheless be appropriate as a matter of scholarly or professional practice.
- Public Domain: Works in the public domain are not subject to copyright restrictions, for example, because copyright has expired or does not apply. In some juristictions, public domain works may carry the requirement of author attribution. This is a moral right that could last forever. They can generally be reused, adapted, and redistributed without copyright permission. Creative Commons also provides a Public Domain Mark that can be used to identify works that are already free of known copyright restrictions.Note that since there is no harmonised international public domain, a work can be in the public domain in one country, and not in another.
(Creative Commons, 2026a)

A particularly important distinction concerns the NoDerivatives (ND) condition. Under the 4.0 licences, users may adapt an ND-licensed work for their own use, but they may not share that adaptation with others (Creative Commons, 2026c).
Before reusing an OER, users should therefore identify the licence and consider what it permits. They should also check whether the resource contains images, figures, datasets, or other third-party materials that may be subject to different rights or licence conditions (Creative Commons, 2026b).
Attribution: giving appropriate credit
Attribution is a fundamental condition of Creative Commons licences, except for CC0. Note that in some jurisdictions, attribution may last forever due to a moral right. It recognises the original creator, provides transparency about the source of reused material, and enables others to locate the original work (Creative Commons, 2026a).
A practical approach commonly used for Creative Commons materials is TASL (Creative Commons, 2026d):
- Title – title of the original work, where available;
- Author – creator or other party designated for attribution;
- Source – link or reference to the original resource;
- Licence – the Creative Commons licence under which it was shared.
Where a resource has been modified, users should also indicate that changes have been made (Creative Commons, 2026b).
It is good practice to record authorship, source, licence, and modification information while resources are being collected and adapted, rather than reconstructing it at the end of a project. This becomes particularly useful when several resources are being combined.
For further guidance and practical examples of how to provide attribution in different situations, explore the Creative Commons Recommended practices for attribution: https://wiki.creativecommons.org/wiki/Recommended_practices_for_attribution
Adapting, remixing, and licence compatibility
One of the main benefits of OER is the ability to build on existing educational materials rather than creating everything from scratch. Depending on the licence, resources may be translated, updated, reorganised, contextualised, combined, or otherwise adapted for a new teaching and learning environment.
Before sharing an adaptation, however, the licence must be checked. Licences containing the ND condition do not permit the sharing of adapted versions. The SA condition permits adaptation but requires a shared adaptation to use the same or a compatible licence (Creative Commons, 2026c).
Questions become more complex when several openly licensed resources are combined. Creative Commons distinguishes between bringing works together in a collection, where their individual licences can continue to apply separately, and creating an adaptation or remix, where licence compatibility may need to be considered (Creative Commons, 2026c).
Not all CC-licensed materials can therefore be remixed and shared in every combination. Creative Commons provides an Adapter’s Licence Chart and a Licence Compatibility Chart to support these decisions (Creative Commons, 2026c).
A useful process is to identify the licence of each resource before beginning a remix, determine whether materials will be used unchanged or adapted, check whether the intended adaptations are permitted, and verify whether the licences are compatible. Doing this early can prevent the creation of a resource that cannot subsequently be shared in the intended way.
If licence incompatibilities arise and no suitable alternatives with compatible licences are available, other options may need to be considered. For example, it may be possible to contact the copyright holder and ask for permission to use the material under a different or compatible licence. Individual third-party materials may also be excluded from the open licence applied to the overall resource, provided that their different copyright or licensing status is clearly indicated. Where permitted under applicable copyright law, it may also be possible to use material based on an applicable copyright exception or limitation, with appropriate citation and subject to the relevant restrictions. These approaches require particular care, as the resulting resource may contain materials that cannot be reused under the same terms as the openly licensed content.
The ENOEL workshop Embrace the Open: (Re-)using and Creating OER provided a practical resource for exploring these decisions. It focused on the reuse and creation of OER and provides an editable slide deck and a workshop plan. The materials are themselves openly available under CC BY 4.0 and can therefore be reused and adapted with appropriate attribution (European Network of Open Education Librarians, 2024).
Choosing a licence and understanding your context
Copyright and licensing literacy is important not only when reusing OER but also when creating and sharing new resources. Before applying an open licence, creators need to establish that they have the necessary rights to do so. They should also consider co-authors, third-party materials, and any institutional or contractual requirements that may affect the choice of licence (Creative Commons, 2026b). Creators should also understand that Creative Commons licences are ordinarily irrevocable once granted, provided that users follow the licence terms; this is especially important when students or other contributors are asked to agree to open publication of their work.
When choosing a licence, useful questions include:
- Do I have the rights necessary to license this resource?
- Are there co-authors or other rights holders who need to agree?
- Does the resource contain third-party material?
- Do I want others to be able to adapt the resource?
- Do I want to permit commercial reuse?
- Do I want adaptations to remain under the same or a compatible licence?
- Are there institutional policies or contractual requirements that I need to consider?
Licence choice influences future reuse. Creative Commons describes CC BY as its most accommodating licence for dissemination and reuse, while NC, ND, and SA introduce additional restrictions or obligations (Creative Commons, 2026a).
At the same time, Creative Commons licences operate within wider legal and institutional environments. Copyright law, exceptions and limitations, intellectual property policies, employment arrangements, and contractual requirements may differ between countries and institutions. General open licensing guidance, therefore, cannot replace appropriate local advice. A CC licence does not remove other obligations that may apply, such as privacy, data protection, confidentiality, moral rights, consent, or other ethical requirements. General open licensing guidance, therefore, cannot replace appropriate local advice.
From licensing to sharing
Applying an open licence is an important step, but making an OER legally reusable does not automatically make it easy for others to find, access, reuse, or adapt. Decisions about format, accessibility, metadata, institutional or project requirements, and where a resource is published can all affect its future shareability.
Effective OER sharing begins before a resource is uploaded to a repository or platform. Several practices can make resources easier for others to find, understand, reuse, and adapt. These include choosing an appropriate open licence and displaying it clearly; providing sufficient metadata and information about authorship and provenance; using accessible and, where possible, editable file formats; clearly identifying third-party content and any different licensing conditions; indicating whether and how a resource has been adapted; and sharing materials through platforms or repositories where they can be discovered and accessed by their intended audiences. Where possible, providing source or editable files alongside final formats can further support adaptation and reuse.
The ENOEL workshop Embrace the Open: Sharing OER provides an opportunity to explore these considerations in greater depth. It invited practitioners to examine potential barriers to sharing OER, features that can make resources more open, accessible, and reusable from the design stage onwards, appropriate Creative Commons licences, and platforms for making OER available. The workshop was accompanied by an openly licensed slide deck and reusable workshop plan, making it both a resource for further guidance and an example of the sharing practices it promotes (European Network of Open Education Librarians, 2024).
The role of libraries and Open Education support
Educators should not necessarily be expected to navigate copyright and licensing questions alone. Libraries and Open Education support services can help build the copyright and licensing literacy needed to work confidently with OER.
Support may include helping educators:
- identify and interpret Creative Commons licences;
- understand attribution requirements;
- recognise third-party copyright issues;
- check adaptation and licence compatibility requirements;
- choose an appropriate licence for their own OER;
- integrate rights and licence information into repository and publication workflows; and
- recognise when specialist copyright or legal advice is required.
The ENOEL Embrace the Open workshop illustrated how Open Education librarians can contribute to this kind of capacity building through practical, reusable training materials (European Network of Open Education Librarians, 2024).
The objective was to develop sufficient copyright and licensing literacy to recognise relevant issues, make informed routine decisions, and know when additional expertise is required.
From legal understanding to collaborative creation
Legal considerations become particularly important when OER are created collaboratively. When students, educators, librarians, and other contributors work together, questions may arise about ownership, attribution, consent to open publication, licence choice, and the use of third-party materials.
Discussing these issues early can help collaborators establish shared expectations and make informed decisions about how their contributions will be recognised, licensed, and shared.
These questions lead to the next section, which explores the opportunities and challenges involved in successful co-creation of OER.
3.3. Making OER co-creation and collaboration work
A key Open Educational Practice is placing people at the heart of Open Education initiatives and involving different stakeholders in the creation of knowledge and educational resources. In academic contexts, collaboration between students, teaching staff, librarians, and other educational professionals can bring together different forms of expertise and experience.
Co-creation can contribute to OER that are more relevant to their intended audiences and reflect a wider range of perspectives. Students contribute their experiences as learners and users of educational materials; teaching staff contribute disciplinary and pedagogical expertise; and librarians can contribute expertise in areas such as finding and evaluating OER, copyright and open licensing, accessibility, metadata, publishing, and dissemination. Case studies of collaborative OER projects demonstrate how these complementary roles can support both OER development and student engagement (McGeary et al., 2021).
However, successful co-creation requires more than inviting different stakeholders to participate. It requires meaningful participation, clear roles and expectations, and consideration of workload, recognition, authorship, licensing, accessibility, and sustainability. This section explores the benefits of OER co-creation for students and staff and considers how libraries can facilitate successful collaborative projects.
OER co-creation: The student advantage
One of the objectives of many OER created in educational institutions is to contribute to student learning by making educational materials engaging, relevant, and responsive to learner needs. In this endeavour, the student voice can become an important part of the creation process.
Involving students in OER creation shifts their role from being solely users of educational materials towards becoming active contributors to knowledge and learning resources. This idea is closely connected to approaches such as Students as Partners and Student as Producer, which emphasise more participatory relationships between students and educators and recognise students as contributors to knowledge creation (Watling, 2012; Lubicz-Nawrocka, 2018).
Depending on the project, students may research and write content, create examples or exercises, produce multimedia materials, review resources from a learner perspective, or contribute to decisions about the structure and presentation of an OER. Creating resources for use beyond an individual assignment can also give student work a wider audience and purpose. Open textbook projects involving students have been associated with opportunities to develop research, writing, editing, teamwork, and digital literacy skills (Mays, 2017).
Participation in OER co-creation can therefore support:
- Collaboration and communication skills: Students gain experience in planning, feedback, negotiation, and collaborative decision-making.
- Digital and content creation skills: Students may work with authoring platforms, multimedia, editing, accessibility practices, and other digital tools.
- Information and OER literacy: Students can develop knowledge of how to find and evaluate information, as well as copyright, attribution, and open licensing.
- Pedagogical awareness: Creating a resource for other learners encourages reflection on explanations, examples, structure, learning needs, and accessibility.
- Agency and ownership: Students can experience themselves as contributors to knowledge rather than solely as recipients of educational content.
Co-creation can also benefit the OER itself. Students can identify explanations that are difficult to understand, suggest examples relevant to learners, identify usability or accessibility barriers, and contribute perspectives that may otherwise be missing. Research on student–staff co-creation more broadly also points to benefits such as shared responsibility, mutual learning, trust, and the development of collaborative learning communities (Lubicz-Nawrocka, 2018).
Meaningful participation is essential, however. Students should understand what they can influence, how decisions are made, how their work will be attributed, and what it means for their contributions to be shared openly.
OER co-creation: Benefits for staff
Co-creation is not only beneficial for students. Teaching staff can gain direct insight into how learners understand and use educational materials. Student contributions may reveal where explanations need clarification, which examples resonate with learners, or where a resource could become more accessible or inclusive. Co-creation can therefore provide an opportunity to reconsider both educational resources and teaching practices.
Collaboration can also distribute expertise. Creating an OER involves much more than writing subject content. It may require knowledge of project management, copyright and licensing, resource discovery, accessibility, editing, metadata, technical production, publishing, and dissemination. These responsibilities do not need to rest with one person.
Libraries can play an important role in bringing these different elements together. Research on faculty–student–library OER projects shows that librarians can move beyond providing individual training or resource discovery towards facilitating projects, coordinating workflows, and supporting sustainable OER creation (McGeary et al., 2021). Other faculty–library collaborations demonstrate how librarians can contribute to OER selection, organisation, course integration, and the development of new openly licensed materials (Whealan-George & Casey, 2020).
The ENOEL workshop #3 Embrace the Open: How the Open Textbook Publishing Kitchen Works provides a practical illustration of this collaborative perspective. The workshop introduced the processes and different forms of expertise involved in open textbook publishing and was facilitated by Open Education practitioners from several European institutions (European Network of Open Education Librarians, 2023). Thinking of OER production as a “publishing kitchen” is useful because it makes visible that producing an open textbook or other substantial OER is rarely the work of a single author.
Collaboration around OER can therefore also contribute to institutional capacity building. Expertise is shared across professional boundaries, relationships between educators and support services are strengthened, and knowledge developed through one project can inform future Open Education initiatives.
Collaboration can also extend beyond individual institutions. The ENOEL Open Education Benefits Toolkit provides an example of a resource developed and progressively adapted through a professional network. ENOEL members contributed to its development, translation, localisation, and reuse across multiple languages and contexts. The resources themselves are provided in editable formats under an open licence. Experiences from creators, localisers, and reusers were also shared through an ENOEL Open Education Café online event, providing an opportunity to reflect on the challenges and practices involved in adapting and using the Toolkit in different contexts. This example illustrates how co-creation can support not only the production of an OER, but also its continuing reuse, localisation, feedback, and improvement by a wider community (European Network of Open Education Librarians, 2026)
OER co-creation: Overcoming challenges
Collaboration does not automatically lead to successful co-creation. OER projects require time, coordination, and decisions about responsibilities, and they may expose differences in expectations or power between participants.
Several things should be considered early on in a project:
- Roles and responsibilities: Who is responsible for content, review, editing, licensing, technical production, publication, and project coordination?
- Meaningful student participation: What decisions can students influence, and how can their contributions move beyond tokenistic participation?
- Workload and recognition: How will the time and labour contributed by students, educators, librarians, and other participants be recognised or compensated?
- Authorship and attribution: Who will be identified as an author or contributor, and how will individual contributions be acknowledged?
- Copyright and licensing: Do participants understand how their contributions will be licensed and shared? Have third-party materials been checked?
- Consent and student rights: How are potential power imbalances between staff and students addressed? Students should be able to decline the open publication of their work without academic disadvantage and should be offered a genuinely equivalent alternative. Is consent informed and voluntary, and can students reconsider their decision where appropriate?
- Accessibility and inclusion: Can all participants contribute meaningfully, and is accessibility considered throughout the creation process?
- Sustainability: Who will update, maintain, and respond to feedback about the resource after the initial project has ended?
These questions are particularly important when students contribute work that will be published openly.
Depending on institutional policy and local legal frameworks, students may retain copyright in the work they create, so ownership, attribution, licence choice, and consent to open publication should be discussed before publication. Naming students or other contributors publicly can raise privacy and data protection concerns. A contributor agreement can help clarify who owns the work, how contributors will be attributed, which licence will apply, whether consent has been given for open publication, and who will be responsible for future updates or maintenance.
Practical guidance on creating open textbooks with students therefore emphasises student rights and faculty responsibilities alongside licensing, privacy, digital literacy, and agreements between students and teaching staff (Mays, 2017). Research on library-supported open pedagogy projects similarly highlights the importance of defining the scope of library involvement, protecting students’ rights as authors, and developing sustainable support models for library staff (Carter & Santiago, 2023).
The ENOEL Embrace the Open workshop series provided practical resources for addressing different parts of this process. Workshop #3 How the Open Textbook Publishing Kitchen Works provided insight into open textbook publishing processes and collaborative workflows (European Network of Open Education Librarians, 2023). Workshop #6, (Re-)using and Creating OER, complemented this perspective by focusing on identifying OER for reuse, selecting resources that fit learner needs, adapting OER in accordance with their licences, and considering accessibility and reusability when creating new materials (European Network of Open Education Librarians, 2024).
Successful OER co-creation, therefore, depends not simply on bringing people together, but on creating a transparent and supportive collaborative process. When roles, rights, expectations, and responsibilities are discussed from the outset, students, teaching staff, librarians, and other contributors can bring their different forms of expertise to the project while developing a shared understanding of what they are creating and how it will be used.
Before starting an OER co-creation project, it can be useful to consider:
- Who should be involved, and what expertise or perspective does each participant bring?
- What decisions will students and other contributors be able to influence?
- How will roles, responsibilities, workload, and timelines be agreed upon?
- How will authorship, attribution, and recognition be handled?
- Have copyright, third-party materials, and the intended open licence been discussed?
- Have students given informed consent for their work to be shared openly, given that CC licences are irrevocable? Have they been provided non-open alternatives?
- How will accessibility and inclusive participation be supported?
- Who will be responsible for publishing, maintaining, and updating the OER?
Co-creation can make OER development a learning process in itself. When collaboration is meaningful and appropriately supported, the result is not only an openly licensed resource but also an opportunity to develop skills, share expertise, strengthen relationships, and build capacity for future Open Educational Practices.
Working effectively with Open Educational Resources (OER) involves more than finding or creating openly licensed materials. Open Educational Practices (OEP) also require educators, librarians, students, and other stakeholders to make informed decisions about the quality and suitability of resources, understand the legal conditions that enable reuse and adaptation, and develop collaborative approaches to creating and improving OER.
In this chapter, we explored three interconnected dimensions of Open Educational Practice: building trust in the quality of existing OER, navigating copyright and open licensing, and developing successful student–staff–library collaborations in OER creation. Together, these perspectives demonstrate that effective OER practice depends not only on resources and licences, but also on informed judgement, appropriate support, clear responsibilities, and collaboration.
3.4 Chapter Key takeways
Working effectively with Open Educational Resources (OER) involves more than finding or creating openly licensed materials. Open Educational Practices (OEP) also require educators, librarians, students, and other stakeholders to make informed decisions about the quality and suitability of resources, understand the legal conditions that enable reuse and adaptation, and develop collaborative approaches to creating and improving OER.
In this chapter, we explored three interconnected dimensions of Open Educational Practice: building trust in the quality of existing OER, navigating copyright and open licensing, and developing successful student–staff–library collaborations in OER creation. Together, these perspectives demonstrate that effective OER practice depends not only on resources and licences, but also on informed judgement, appropriate support, clear responsibilities, and collaboration.
Key takeaways
- Trust is important for OER adoption and reuse: Educators and other users need to be able to assess whether an OER is reliable, relevant, usable, and appropriate for their particular educational context.
- Quality is contextual and multidimensional: The quality of an OER cannot be determined by a single criterion. Content accuracy, pedagogical suitability, usability, accessibility, openness, adaptability, and contextual relevance can all influence whether a resource is fit for a particular purpose.
- Quality assurance can take different forms: Evaluation frameworks, rubrics, peer review, repository curation, metadata, and community-based approaches can provide useful signals and support informed decisions about selecting and reusing OER.
- Openness can support continuous quality improvement: Because OER can be reused and adapted, resources can be corrected, updated, contextualised, translated, and improved over time. Quality can therefore be understood not only as a characteristic of a finished resource, but also as part of an ongoing process of review and adaptation.
- Open licensing enables reuse, but requires legal understanding: Copyright, Creative Commons licences, attribution requirements, adaptation, and licence compatibility need to be considered when reusing, remixing, creating, and sharing OER.
- Legal clarity can build confidence: Clear guidance and access to appropriate expertise can help educators and students make informed decisions about what they are permitted to reuse and adapt, and how to openly share their own contributions in their own contexts.
- OER creation can be a collaborative process: Students, educators, librarians, and other professionals can contribute different forms of knowledge and expertise to the creation and development of OER.
- Successful co-creation requires more than participation: Clear roles and expectations, communication, appropriate support, recognition of contributions, and attention to decision-making can help create meaningful and sustainable collaborative processes.
- Libraries and support professionals can connect these different practices: Expertise in resource discovery, quality evaluation, copyright and licensing, metadata, publishing, and Open Education can help individuals and teams move from finding OER to confidently reusing, adapting, creating, and sharing them.
- Quality, legal understanding, and collaboration reinforce one another: These dimensions should not be treated as isolated steps. Evaluating an OER can lead to adaptation, adaptation raises licensing and attribution questions, and collaborative creation introduces further considerations around contributions, responsibilities, and sharing.
By connecting quality and trust, legal understanding, and collaborative creation, this chapter provides practical perspectives for working with OER throughout their lifecycle. The approaches and resources presented can serve as starting points for evaluating existing materials, making informed decisions about reuse and adaptation, and developing collaborative Open Educational Practices in different educational and institutional contexts.
NOW WHAT? A few questions you might want to ask yourself
Having explored quality and trust, legal frameworks, and collaborative OER creation, take a moment to consider how these dimensions relate to your own professional or institutional context. Working openly often involves making decisions rather than following a single prescribed approach, and practices that work well in one context may need to be adapted in another. Use the questions below to reflect on your current practices, identify areas where further support may be needed, and consider what you could take forward.
- When evaluating an OER, what makes you trust that it is accurate, appropriate, accessible and suitable for your learners?
- What processes, tools or expertise are available in your institution to support OER evaluation, licensing, adaptation and sharing?
- How confident are you in applying Creative Commons licences, providing attribution and assessing whether resources can be adapted or remixed?
- How could students, librarians, educators and other professionals contribute meaningfully to OER creation or adaptation in your context?
- What conditions would support ethical and sustainable co-creation, including clear roles, informed consent, recognition, workload and responsibility for maintaining the resource?
- What is one practical action or collaboration you could initiate to strengthen the reuse, adaptation or creation of OER in your context?
3.5 References
Atenas, J., & Havemann, L. (2013). Quality assurance in the open: An evaluation of OER repositories. INNOQUAL: The International Journal for Innovation and Quality in Learning, 1(2), 22–34. https://oro.open.ac.uk/56347/1/30-288-1-PB%5B1%5D.pdf
Atenas, J., & Havemann, L. (2014). Questions of quality in repositories of open educational resources: A literature review. Research in Learning Technology, 22, 20889. https://doi.org/10.3402/rlt.v22.20889
Baas, M., Admiraal, W., & van den Berg, E. (2019). Teachers’ adoption of open educational resources in higher education. Journal of Interactive Media in Education, 2019(1), Article 9. https://doi.org/10.5334/jime.510
Camilleri, A. F., Ehlers, U. D., & Pawlowski, J. (2014). State of the art review of quality issues related to Open Educational Resources (OER). Publications Office of the European Union. https://doi.org/10.2791/80171
Carter, K. M., & Santiago, A. (2023). Exploring sustainability in library support for open pedagogy collaborations. Communications in Information Literacy, 17(1), 238–259. https://doi.org/10.15760/comminfolit.2023.17.1.3
Clements, K., Pawlowski, J., & Manouselis, N. (2015). Open educational resources repositories literature review – Towards a comprehensive quality approaches framework. Computers in Human Behavior, 51, 1098–1106. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chb.2015.03.026
Cox, G., & Trotter, H. (2017). An OER framework, heuristic and lens: Tools for understanding lecturers’ adoption of OER. Open Praxis, 9(2), 151–171. https://doi.org/10.5944/openpraxis.9.2.571
Creative Commons. (2026a). Creative Commons Licenses. Creative Commons. https://creativecommons.org/share-your-work/use-remix/cc-licenses/
Creative Commons. (2026b). Marking your work with a CC license. Creative Commons Wiki. https://wiki.creativecommons.org/wiki/Marking_your_work_with_a_CC_license
Creative Commons. (2026c). 4.4 Remixing CC-Licensed Work. Creative Commons Certificate for Educators, Academic Librarians, and Open Culture. https://creativecommons.org/course/cc-cert-edu/unit-4-using-cc-licenses-and-cc-licensed-works/4-4-remixing-cc-licensed-work/
Creative Commons. (2026d). Recommended practices for attribution. Creative Commons Wiki. https://wiki.creativecommons.org/wiki/Recommended_practices_for_attribution
European Network of Open Education Librarians. (2023). ENOEL WS#3 – Embrace the Open: How the Open Textbook publishing kitchen works [Workshop materials]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.8338085
European Network of Open Education Librarians. (2024). ENOEL WS#4 – Embrace the Open: OE Librarianship 101 [Workshop materials]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.10573410
European Network of Open Education Librarians. (2024). ENOEL WS#6 – Embrace the Open: (Re-)using and creating OER [Workshop materials]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.10845596
European Network of Open Education Librarians. (2024, April 18). ENOEL WS#7 – Embrace the Open: Sharing OER [Workshop materials]. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.10991226
Lubicz-Nawrocka, T. (2018). Students as partners in learning and teaching: The benefits of co-creation of the curriculum. International Journal for Students as Partners, 2(1), 47–63. https://doi.org/10.15173/ijsap.v2i1.3207
Mays, E. (Ed.). (2017). A guide to making open textbooks with students. Rebus Community. https://press.rebus.community/makingopentextbookswithstudents/
McGeary, B., Guder, C., & Ganeshan, A. (2021). Opening up educational practices through faculty, librarian, and student collaboration in OER creation: Moving from labor-intensive to supervisory involvement. Partnership: The Canadian Journal of Library and Information Practice and Research, 16(1), 1–27. https://doi.org/10.21083/partnership.v16i1.6149
Proudman, V., Santos-Hermosa, G., Smith, J., & Ficarra, V. (2020). Open Education in European Libraries of Higher Education. SPARC Europe. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.3903175
Santos-Hermosa, G. (2024). Impact and implementation of UNESCO’s Recommendation on Open Educational Resources in academic libraries: SPARC Europe case study. Research in Learning Technology, 32, 3183. https://doi.org/10.25304/rlt.v32.3183
Santos-Hermosa, G., Proudman, V., & Corti, P. (2022). Open Education in European Libraries of Higher Education: Implementing the UNESCO OER Recommendation. SPARC Europe. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.7244713
SURF. (n.d.). Roadmap Quality Model for OER (English version). edusources. https://use.edusources.nl/collectie-leermaterialen-beheren/steps/stappenplan-kwaliteitsmodel-voor-open-leermaterialen (last retrieved: 2 September 2026)
UNESCO. (2019). Recommendation on Open Educational Resources (OER). https://www.unesco.org/en/legal-affairs/recommendation-open-educational-resources-oer
Watling, S. (2012). Student as producer and open educational resources: Enhancing learning through digital scholarship. Enhancing Learning in the Social Sciences, 4(3), 1–7. https://doi.org/10.11120/elss.2012.04030013
Whealan-George, K., & Casey, A. M. (2020). Collaboration between library, faculty, and instructional design to increase all open educational resources for curriculum development and delivery. The Reference Librarian, 61(2), 97–112. https://doi.org/10.1080/02763877.2020.1749753
Yuan, M., & Recker, M. (2015). Not all rubrics are equal: A review of rubrics for evaluating the quality of Open Educational Resources. The International Review of Research in Open and Distributed Learning, 16(5). https://doi.org/10.19173/irrodl.v16i5.2389
3.6 Appendix: Chapter 3 Reused resources
Reused resource 1
Embracing Pedagogical Partnership: What Kind of Mindset, Courage, and Practices Are Necessary?
WHAT?
- Title: Embracing Pedagogical Partnership: What Kind of Mindset, Courage, and Practices Are Necessary?
- Description: A set of slides capturing a workshop held on May 8, 2025, exploring the transformative potential of authentic student-staff partnerships as a strategic approach to advancing student engagement, success, and institutional effectiveness. The slides include case studies of projects carried out in Ireland. They provide interesting talking points, guidelines and reflections on student-staff partnerships in higher education.
WHO?
- Authors: members of the European Network of Open Education Librarians.
- Collaborators: SPARC Europe staff for the communication and the design of the tools, as well as all researchers and practitioners who contributed evidence-based publications on the benefits of Open Education.
WHY IS THIS EXAMPLE IMPORTANT?
The resource can help open education librarians to:
- Understand the principles and value of authentic student-staff partnerships in teaching, learning, and institutional development.
- Learn directly from Irish practitioners and students engaged in real-world collaborative projects.
- Gain practical frameworks and case studies to inspire new or enhance existing partnership initiatives.
- Explore issues of power, inclusion, and trust-building essential to sustainable partnership work.
WHAT CAN YOU DO WITH THIS INFORMATION?
- Use the slide deck as a staff development resource to introduce the concept of student-staff partnership within your department or team.
- Adapt examples and frameworks from the presentation to inform your own partnership policies, pilot projects, or programme reviews.
CC LICENCE:
Reused resource 2
An ENOEL Toolkit: Open Education Benefits. Version 7
WHAT?
- Title: An ENOEL Toolkit: Open Education Benefits
- Description: It is a set of tools (slides, leaflets, cards and a card game) prepared by the European Network of Open Education Librarians (ENOEL). The toolkit aims to raise awareness of the importance of Open Education and highlights benefits for students, teachers, institutions, society, and librarians. It comes with a list of references that point to evidence-based benefits of open education across a diverse range of contexts.
- Finalist for the OE Award of Excellence for the category “Open reuse/remix/adaptation”
WHO?
- Authors: members of the European Network of Open Education Librarians.
- Collaborators: SPARC Europe staff for the communication and the design of the tools, as well as all researchers and practitioners who contributed evidence-based publications on the benefits of Open Education.
WHY IS THIS EXAMPLE IMPORTANT?
- Evidence-based: all the benefits were extracted by librarians from published articles and data-driven research. References are provided in a separate file (English only), together with the tools themselves.
- Adaptation: the tools are intended to be as easy as possible to adapt to specific contexts to promote open education and its benefits, prioritising what is most relevant to local needs. Each tool comes with detailed instructions on how to adapt both texts and graphic elements easily, and how to attribute the derivative work properly.
- Multiple languages: the Toolkit was created in English but is currently available in multiple EU languages and Kazakh. This effort required time and commitment from members who volunteered to translate it. Still, it is key to being more inclusive, advocating more effectively at the local level, and enabling further adaptations to local needs and priorities.
- Process: the Toolkit was created through a co-design activity among librarians and facilitators in the ENOEL, and implemented through a collaborative process that focused specifically on creating an easy-to-adapt output, both graphically and content-wise.
- Empowerment: Librarians took responsibility for using project management templates behind the scenes, recognising the value of having key messages available in multiple languages. They had the opportunity to work with colleagues from other institutions in small teams and to be recognised for their contribution by the larger Open Education community.
- Openness: Released under the CC BY license, it promotes adaptation to specific local contexts.
WHAT CAN YOU DO WITH THIS INFORMATION?
- Adapt the Toolkit’s materials and messages to different stakeholder groups and local contexts.
- Use the provided evidence and references to support Open Education advocacy and awareness-raising.
- Explore the Toolkit as an example of how OER can be designed for reuse, adaptation, translation, and remixing.
- Apply appropriate attribution and licensing practices when adapting the materials.
- Draw inspiration from its collaborative development process when planning your own co-creation or Open Education activities.
CC LICENCE:
Reused resource 3
ENOEL WS#6 – Embrace the Open: (Re-)using and Creating OER
WHAT?
- Title: ENOEL WS#6 – Embrace the Open: (Re-)using and Creating OER
- Description: This recorded workshop is part of the European Network of Open Education Librarians (ENOEL) “Embrace the Open” workshop series. It provides practical guidance on how to identify, select, reuse, adapt, create, and share Open Educational Resources (OER). The workshop encourages participants to consider not only the topic of an educational resource, but also its format, licence, context, accessibility, reusability, and suitability for students’ learning needs. It also introduces practical considerations for adapting existing OER, acknowledging authors appropriately, and selecting suitable licences when creating and sharing new resources. The workshop is accompanied by openly available slides and a workshop plan on Zenodo.
WHO?
- Author/Creator: European Network of Open Education Librarians (ENOEL), SPARC Europe
- Facilitator: Zuzana Stožická, Slovak Centre of Scientific and Technical Information (Slovakia)
WHY IS THIS EXAMPLE IMPORTANT?
- It provides a practical introduction to the process of selecting, reusing, adapting, and creating OER rather than treating these activities as separate practices.
- It highlights that selecting an OER involves more than finding relevant content. Educators also need to consider the format, licence, context, and the learning needs of their students.
- It connects the evaluation of existing OER with the possibility of adaptation: an existing resource need not be used unchanged but can, where its licence permits, be modified to better fit a particular educational context.
- It draws attention to accessibility and reusability as considerations when creating educational resources, helping authors think beyond their immediate use context.
- It demonstrates how open licensing and attribution are connected to practical decisions about reuse and adaptation.
- As part of the ENOEL workshop series, it also illustrates the role that librarians and Open Education professionals can play in building capacity and supporting educators in working confidently with OER.
- The accompanying workshop materials provide an example of how Open Education training resources can themselves be openly shared for further use.
WHAT CAN YOU DO WITH THIS INFORMATION?
- Use the recording as an introductory professional development resource for educators, librarians, educational developers, and others who want to learn more about reusing and creating OER.
- Use the considerations presented in the workshop when evaluating whether an existing OER is suitable for a particular teaching and learning context.
- Apply the workshop’s approach when deciding whether to reuse an OER as is, adapt it to meet local needs, or use it as a starting point for creating a new resource.
- Use the workshop to initiate discussions about quality, relevance, accessibility, reusability, licensing, and attribution when selecting or creating OER.
- Incorporate the recording or accompanying materials into institutional OER training or professional development activities.
- Consult and reuse the accompanying workshop slides and workshop plan available through Zenodo when developing your own OER training activities, subject to the licence conditions stated for those materials.
https://youtube.com/watch?v=uaHWvTicY0I%3Fsi%3Dawsc4qqstP3W4HMJ
CC LICENCE:
Reused resource 4
ENOEL WS#4 – Embrace the Open: OE Librarianship 101
WHAT?
- A practical workshop resource developed within the European Network of Open Education Librarians (ENOEL) to support librarians and other Open Education practitioners in developing their Open Education practice.
- Title: ENOEL WS#4 – Embrace the Open: OE Librarianship 101
- The workshop introduces key aspects of Open Education librarianship and provides practical activities for reflecting on the role of librarians in supporting OER.
- Description: The workshop is part of ENOEL’s Embrace the Open series. Of particular relevance to this chapter is its focus on selecting criteria for identifying high-quality OER collections. It connects the evaluation and selection of OER with questions of reusability, adaptability, shareability, licensing, and the role librarians can play in Open Educational Practices.
WHO?
- Author: European Network of Open Education Librarians (ENOEL)
WHY IS THIS EXAMPLE IMPORTANT?
- It translates questions around OER quality into practical activities.
- It encourages librarians to consider criteria for identifying high-quality OER collections.
- It connects quality assessment with reusability and adaptability.
- It illustrates how librarians can support educators in finding and selecting appropriate OER.
- It provides an example of capacity building developed by and for the European Open Education library community.
WHAT CAN YOU DO WITH THIS INFORMATION?
- Use the workshop materials for professional development and staff training.
- Adapt the activities to discuss OER quality in your own institution.
- Use the questions and criteria as a starting point for evaluating OER collections.
- Reflect on the role your library or support service can play in helping educators identify trustworthy and reusable OER.
- Use the resource as inspiration for developing your own OER training activities.
CC LICENCE:
Reused resource 5
Open Education in European Libraries of Higher Education
WHAT?
- A European survey report providing evidence about Open Education and OER practices in academic libraries.
- Title: Open Education in European Libraries of Higher Education
- The report presents findings from a survey of 146 academic library professionals from 29 European countries and provides insights into Open Education policies, practices, challenges, and support within European academic libraries.
- Description: SPARC Europe prepared the report in consultation with the European Network of Open Education Librarians (ENOEL). It provides an evidence-based overview of how academic libraries across Europe engage with Open Education and OER and examines their role in supporting the development of Open Education.
- For this chapter, the report is particularly useful for understanding OER quality and trust not only as questions concerning individual resources, but also as issues connected to institutional support, professional expertise, infrastructure, and Open Education practice.
WHO?
- Authors: Vanessa Proudman, Gema Santos-Hermosa, Jen Smith, and Victoria Ficarra
- Prepared by: SPARC Europe in consultation with the European Network of Open Education Librarians (ENOEL)
WHY IS THIS EXAMPLE IMPORTANT?
- It provides empirical evidence about Open Education practices in European academic libraries.
- It illustrates the role libraries can play in supporting educators and institutions working with OER.
- It places questions of OER quality and trust within the wider context of institutional Open Education practice.
- It provides a European perspective based on experiences from 29 countries.
- It demonstrates how library communities can gather evidence to inform the further development of Open Education support.
WHAT CAN YOU DO WITH THIS INFORMATION?
- Use the findings to reflect on the role of your own library or institution in supporting OER.
- Compare the practices and challenges described in the report with your own institutional context.
- Use the evidence to support discussions with institutional leaders, educators, librarians, and Open Education practitioners.
- Identify areas in which additional OER support, professional development, infrastructure, or collaboration may be needed.
- Use the report as a starting point for benchmarking or developing your institution’s Open Education activities.
CC LICENCE:
Reused resource 6
ENOEL WS#3 – Embrace the Open: How the Open Textbook Publishing Kitchen Works
WHAT?
- Title: ENOEL WS#3 – Embrace the Open: How the Open Textbook Publishing Kitchen Works
- Description: This resource contains the presentation and workshop plan developed for the third workshop in the European Network of Open Education Librarians (ENOEL) “Embrace the Open” workshop series. The workshop uses the metaphor of an open textbook “publishing kitchen” to explore how open textbooks can be created and published through collaborative workflows. It brings together different roles and areas of expertise involved in open textbook publishing. It provides a practical perspective on how collaboration can support the development, publication, and sharing of openly licensed educational resources.
WHO?
- Author/Creator: European Network of Open Education Librarians (ENOEL), SPARC Europe
- Contributors/Facilitators: Sylvia Moes, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam; Mira Buist-Zhuk, University of Groningen; Margreet Nieborg, University of Groningen; Lambert Heller, TIB; Simon Worthington, TIB
WHY IS THIS EXAMPLE IMPORTANT?
- It provides a practical example of collaborative approaches to open textbook creation and publishing.
- It illustrates that creating an open textbook involves multiple roles, skills, and areas of expertise rather than being the sole responsibility of an individual author.
- It highlights the value of collaboration between educators, librarians, publishing professionals, and other Open Education practitioners.
- It helps make the workflows behind open textbook publishing more visible and easier to understand.
- It connects particularly well with this chapter’s discussion of student–staff–library collaboration and the role of libraries and support professionals in OER creation.
- As an ENOEL workshop, it also demonstrates how professional communities can build capacity by sharing practical knowledge and reusable training materials.
WHAT CAN YOU DO WITH THIS INFORMATION?
- Use the workshop materials to initiate discussions about the different roles involved in creating and publishing an open textbook.
- Use the “publishing kitchen” approach to reflect on which expertise, responsibilities, and support structures are needed for an OER or open textbook project in your own institution.
- Adapt the workshop materials for professional development or training activities with librarians, educators, educational developers, publishers, students, or other contributors to OER projects.
- Use the resource when planning collaborative OER projects to clarify roles, responsibilities, workflows, and areas in which additional expertise or institutional support may be needed.
- Compare the collaborative publishing approach presented in the workshop with existing OER creation and publishing workflows at your own institution.
- Reuse or adapt the openly licensed presentation and workshop plan when developing your own Open Education training activities.
- DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.8338085
- Workshop recording:
https://youtube.com/watch?v=yjqNQ7dMHrE%3Fsi%3DcgOoyrUtwKkxfOr3
CC LICENCE:
Reused resource 7
ENOEL WS#7 – Embrace the Open: Sharing OER
WHAT?
- Title: ENOEL WS#7 – Embrace the Open: Sharing OER
- Description: This resource contains the presentation and workshop plan developed for the third workshop in the European Network of Open Education Librarians (ENOEL) “Embrace the Open” workshop series. The workshop helped participants analyse how to share learning resources, taking into consideration different perspectives: format, project requirements, institutional policies, etc., exploring potential challenges to sharing OER and identifying features during the resource design process that make content more open, accessible and shareable. It also supported discussing how to select the appropriate CC licence and explored platforms where OER are made available and where creators can upload theirs.
WHO?
- Authors: members of the European Network of Open Education Librarians.
- Contributors/Facilitators: Marta Bustillo from University College Dublin (Ireland), Kamila Kokot-Kanikula from Gdansk University of Technology (Poland), and Peter Vedal Utnes from The Arctic University of Norway (Norway)
WHY IS THIS EXAMPLE IMPORTANT?
- It addresses sharing as a key step in the OER lifecycle, helping practitioners move from creating or adapting resources to making them genuinely available for others to reuse.
- It takes a practical, multidimensional approach to shareability, considering licensing, formats, accessibility, institutional policies and requirements, and where resources can be shared.
- It combines guidance with reflection on real barriers and challenges, rather than presenting OER sharing as a purely technical process.
- It is itself an example of open practice: the workshop experience is documented through a recording, while the slides and workshop plan are openly licensed CC BY 4.0 and available for reuse and adaptation.
- As an ENOEL workshop, it also demonstrates how professional communities can build capacity by sharing practical knowledge and reusable training materials.
WHAT CAN YOU DO WITH THIS INFORMATION?
- Use the workshop materials to learn or refresh your knowledge about making educational resources more open, accessible and shareable.
- Reuse or adapt the slide deck to introduce OER sharing, licensing and dissemination to educators or colleagues in your own context.
- Reuse the workshop plan to run your own session, adapting the activities, examples, timing and discussion prompts to your audience.
- Use the recording as a facilitation resource: watch it to see how the workshop was delivered, or select relevant parts to support your own professional development.
- Use the questions and activities to start conversations with educators about what may prevent them from sharing their resources and how those barriers could be addressed.
- Combine and adapt the materials for local institutional needs, languages or professional-development programmes, or for your own Open Education training activities.
CC LICENCE:
Reused resource 8
WHAT?
- Title: Roadmap Quality Model for OER
- Description: The goal of the roadmap is to provide guidelines for groups (for example, within an educational institution or professional community) that want to build a collection of open educational resources and draft, implement, and maintain a quality model for open educational resources. The target audience is teachers and people who provide educational support with developing open educational resources, such as educators, media experts, copyright experts, and information specialists. All those interested in sharing and reusing open educational resources and knowledge on the quality of educational resources.
WHO?
- Authors: edusources and SURF team members
- Collaborators: Danny Plass, Linda Le Grand, Marloes van den Broek, Michiel de Jong, Robert Schuwer (more details here)
WHY IS THIS EXAMPLE IMPORTANT?
- It provides a practical approach to OER quality, helping practitioners move from general discussions about quality to defining criteria that can support decisions about whether resources are suitable for use.
- It recognises that quality criteria can be developed collaboratively within an institution or disciplinary community, rather than assuming that one universal quality model will work in every context.
- It explicitly connects quality assessment with trust: shared criteria can help educators feel more confident when evaluating and reusing open learning materials.
- It supports the evaluation of both existing OER and newly created materials, helping practitioners consider quality before resources are openly shared.
- It provides a European example of how quality assurance can support sharing and reuse rather than functioning simply as a gatekeeping mechanism.
- In addition to the step-by-step process, it points practitioners towards background information, examples, best practices, and existing quality models that can inform their own approach.
WHAT CAN YOU DO WITH THIS INFORMATION?
- Use the step-by-step approach to develop or review an OER quality model for your institution, library, project, or disciplinary community.
- Use the proposed process to start a collaborative discussion about what “fit for use” means in your own context and which quality criteria matter most.
- Adapt relevant criteria or examples to create a local checklist or guidance tool for educators who select, create, or share OER.
- Use a shared quality model to help educators evaluate OER more consistently and confidently, while still allowing professional judgement and contextual considerations.
- Consult the examples and existing models referenced in the resource when deciding whether to develop a new framework or adapt an existing one.
- Use the resource in professional development or workshops to explore the relationship between quality, trust, reuse, and sharing of OER.
CC LICENCE:
Download Chapter 3
Download, Adapt and Reuse
The downloadable versions of this textbook are published under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0) licence, unless otherwise indicated. You are welcome to download, copy, edit, adapt and build upon the materials to suit your own educational or institutional context, provided you give appropriate attribution and indicate any changes made.
Feel free to start adapting! We would also love to hear how you are using or building upon the textbook. If you create an adapted version or would like to share your experience, please get in touch with us via oer@sparceurope.org!